Glass ornament shaped like angel wings with a gradient color pattern on a white background
New
Sterling Angel Wings Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Decorative ornament with a cow inside a UFO on a white background
New
Cow Abduction - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Beatrix Potter's Benjamin Bunny Ornament - Old World Christmas
New
Beatrix Potter's Benjamin Bunny Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Capybara ornament holding a pink donut with sprinkles on a white background
New
Capybara Eating Donut Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Glass ornament of a unicorn with wings on a white background
New
Radiant Pegasus Ornament - Old World Christmas

$29.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Colorful dragon ornament on a white background
New
Celestial Dragon Ornament - Old World Christmas

$29.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Book ornament titled 'Llama Llama Red Pajama' with a llama and rabbit illustration on a blue background.
New
Llama Llama Red Pajama Book Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Decorative book ornament with illustrations of cars and trucks, featuring 'Richard Scarry's Cars and Trucks and Things That Go'.
New
Cars & Trucks & Things That Go Book Ornament- Old World Christmas

$24.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Decorative ornament of Santa Claus holding a globe on a white background
New
Santa World Peace Ornament - Old World Christmas

$29.99

Decorative glass ornament with 'Class of 2026' text on a white background
New
Class Of 2026 Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Red glass jar ornament with Smucker's Strawberry Jam label on a white background
New
Smucker's Strawberry Jam Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Decorative ornament shaped like a Jif peanut butter jar on a white background
New
Jif Peanut Butter Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Betty Crocker Cookbook Christmas ornament shaped like an open book with cookies on a white background
New
Betty Crocker Cookbook Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Betty Crocker Gingerbread cookie mix package on a white background
New
Betty Crocker Cookie Mix Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Pillsbury Doughboy Ornament - Old World Christmas
New
Pillsbury Doughboy Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Strawberry Shortcake Lunchbox Ornament Old World Christmas
New
Strawberry Shortcake Lunchbox Ornament - Old World Christmas

$19.99

Decorative black cat ornament with colorful embellishments on a white background
New
Dia De Los Muertos Cat Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Glass ornament of a strawberry shortcake character with pink whipped cream and strawberries on a white background
New
Strawberry Shortcake & Custard Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Glass Corduroy bear ornament holding a book with a purple item, on a white background
New
Corduroy Holding Book Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Glass ornament of a Santa Claus figure from Rudolph the red nose reindeer with a pink jacket on a white background
New
Santa In Suspenders Ornament - Rudolph - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Holly Jolly Mad Libs game packaging with a Christmas-themed illustration on a white background
New
Holly, Jolly Mad Libs Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Decorative ornament shaped like a red apple with a small figure inside on a white background
New
Lowly Worm's Applecar Ornament- Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

D&D Dungeon Master glass ornament of a character in ornate clothing on a white background
New
Dungeons & Dragons Dungeon Master Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Dungeons & Dragons Snowy Owlbear Ornament - Old World Christmas
New
Dungeons & Dragons Snowy Owlbear Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Richard Scary's Bananas Gorilla's Bananamobile Ornament- Old World Christmas
New
Bananas Gorilla's Bananamobile Ornament- Old World Christmas

$27.99

Decorative Martini glass with gingerbread man ornament with a pink base and blue top on a white background
New
Gingerbread Glam Cocktail Ornament- Old World Christmas

$24.99

Magic Black Lotus Card Decorative ornament shaped like a card with a black lotus illustration on a white background
New
Magic: The Gathering Black Lotus Card Ornament- Old World Christmas

$24.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Red Glass dice ornament with white numbers on a white background
New
Dungeons & Dragons d20 Dice Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Lucky Charms cereal box ornament with a rainbow and cartoon character on a white background
New
Lucky Charms Cereal Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Glass ornament shaped like a Cheerios cereal box with a heart-shaped design on a white background
New
Cheerios Cereal Box Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Decorative ornament featuring a character from Lucky Charms on a white background
New
Lucky Charms Cereal Leprechaun Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Trix cereal box ornament with character on a white background
New
Trix Cereal Box Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Glass ornament shaped like a marshmallow with a burnt-out sign on a white background
New
Burnt-Out Marshmallow Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Furry Frenzy Puzzle - Old World Christmas
New
Furry Frenzy Puzzle - Old World Christmas

$19.99

Pastel Nutcracker Soldier Ornament - Old World Christmas
New
Pastel Nutcracker Soldier Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Decorative ornament shaped like a book titled 'Corduroy' with a teddy bear illustration on a red background.
New
Corduroy Book Ornament - Old World Christmas

$24.99

Glass ornament of a girl in a red dress sitting on a purple present against a white background
New
Misfit Doll Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Decorative glass ornament of Llama Llama holding a book on a white background
New
Llama Llama Holding Books Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99

Glass floral highland cow ornament with floral crown on a white background
New
Floral Highland Cow Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Glass ornament of a fox peeking out from a pine cone on a white background
New
Piney Fox Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Decorative glass ornament of a rabbit with a pink scarf in a pinecone on a white background
New
Piney Rabbit Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Glass ornament of a Kawaii brown and white dog with a red collar on a white background
New
Kawaii Dog Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Decorative rainbow ornament with 'love you forever, text on a white background
New
Pawprints On My Heart Ornament

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock

Christmas ornament shaped like a cat wearing a green tree outfit with decorations on a white background.
New
Meowmas Tree Ornament - Old World Christmas

$27.99 Temporarily Out of Stock